Shareholder Rights Project
The Shareholder Rights Project (SRP) is a clinical program operating at Harvard Law School and directed by Professor Lucian Bebchuk. The SRP works on behalf of public pension funds and charitable organizations seeking to improve corporate governance at publicly traded companies, as well as on research and policy projects related to corporate governance. Any views expressed and positions taken by the SRP and its representatives should be attributed solely to the SRP and not to Harvard Law School or Harvard University.

121 Companies Agreeing to Move towards Annual Elections

This page provides information about 121 successful engagements resulting in companies agreeing to move toward annual elections following the submission of board declassification proposals for 2012, 2013 and 2014 meetings. As explained in further detail below, the work of the SRP and SRP-represented investors produced:

In general, the practice of the SRP and SRP-represented investors has been to engage actively with companies receiving declassification proposals. We are pleased by the responsiveness to shareholder concerns displayed by so many corporate boards.


Aggregate 2012–2014 Impact

The outcomes produced by 2012–2014 proposals can be expected to have a major impact on the governance of large publicly traded companies.

In 2012, 2013 and 2014, 196 shareholder proposals were submitted to 129 different S&P 500 and Fortune 500 companies (in a number of cases, where 2012 or 2013 proposal did not result in companies agreeing to move towards annual elections, proposals were also submitted to companies for their subsequent 2013 or 2014 annual meetings). Of the 129 companies receiving proposals for 2012, 2013 and/or 2014 meetings, 121 companies – over 85% of the companies receiving proposals in 2012, 2013 and/or 2014 – have by now agreed to move towards annual elections. These 121 companies represent about two-thirds of the S&P 500 companies that had classified boards as of the beginning of 2012, and had a market capitalization exceeding one trillion dollars as of December 6, 2013.


Successful Engagements Following 2012 Proposals

Following the submission of shareholder proposals for voting at the 2012 annual meetings of 89 S&P 500 companies with classified boards, 50 companies – more than half of the companies receiving proposals – agreed to move toward annual elections.

Table 1 below lists these companies and the proponents that submitted the shareholder proposals. 37 agreed-upon management proposals (listed in Panel A of Table 1) went to a vote at 2012 annual meetings; these proposals passed at 31 companies, resulting in 31 board declassifications (listed in the Declassifications page), and received majority support but failed to pass due to the presence of 80% supermajority requirements at six companies. A number of agreements reached (listed in Panel B of Table 1) with respect to 2012 annual meetings called for companies to bring management proposals at pending annual meetings. Additionally, 2 companies (listed in Panel C of Table 1) decided to bring management proposal to declassify shortly after the passage of 2012 declassification proposals by SRP-represented investors.


Successful Engagements Following 2013 Proposals

For the 2013 proxy season, the SRP and SRP-represented investors submitted 76 shareholder declassification proposals to S&P 500 and Fortune 500 companies with classified boards. These proposals have already resulted in 52 companies – more than 60% of the companies receiving proposals – agreeing to move towards annual elections.

Table 2 below lists those of the 52 companies that have publicly announced the agreed-upon moves towards annual elections. Of these 52 companies, 47 companies entered into agreements to bring management declassification proposals for shareholder approval. Panel A of Table 2 lists those of the 47 companies that have already publicly announced the agreed-upon management proposals; this list is updated periodically as additional companies publicly announce agreed-upon management proposals. Of the 47 agreed-upon management proposals, 40 have already been voted on at 2013 annual meetings, and the other 7 agreed-upon management proposals will go to a vote in the future. In addition, 5 companies have declassified by amending their bylaws (where companies’ classified board structures are set out in their bylaws, they may declassify without a shareholder vote). These companies are listed in Panel B of Table 2.


Successful Engagements Following 2014 Proposals

For the 2014 proxy season, the SRP and SRP-represented investors submitted 31 shareholder declassification proposals to S&P 500 and Fortune 500 companies with classified boards. These proposals have already resulted in 24 companies agreeing to move towards annual elections.

Table 3 below lists those of the 24 companies that have already publicly announced the agreed-upon management proposals; this list is updated periodically as additional companies publicly announce agreed-upon management proposals.


Table 1: Successful Engagements Following 2012 Proposals

Company Proponent
Panel A: Agreed-Upon Management Proposals to
Declassify that Went to a Vote in 2012
Akamai Technologies, Inc. (AKAM) ISBI
Alcoa Inc. (AA) NCDST
Amphenol Corporation (APH) NCF
BlackRock, Inc. (BLK) ISBI
C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc. (CHRW) NCF
C.R. Bard, Inc. (BCR) OPERS
Cabot Oil & Gas Corporation (COG) NCDST
Cameron International Corporation (CAM) NCDST
CenturyLink, Inc. (CTL) ISBI
CIGNA Corporation (CI) OPERS
Citrix Systems, Inc. (CTXS) NCF
Coventry Health Care, Inc. (CVH) ISBI
DeVRY, Inc. (DV) PRIM
Eli Lilly and Company (LLY) NCF
FMC Technologies, Inc. (FTI) NCDST
Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. (FIS) ISBI
Flowserve Corporation (FLS) NCDST
GameStop Corp. (GME) NCF
Helmerich & Payne (HP) NCDST
Hudson City Bancorp, Inc. (HCBK) NCF
Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (ISRG) NCDST
Janus Capital Group Inc. (JNS) NCDST
JDS Uniphase Corporation (JDSU) PRIM
Juniper Networks, Inc. (JNPR) ISBI
KLA-Tencor Corporation (KLAC) PRIM
McDonald’s Corporation (MCD) LACERA
NRG Energy, Inc. (NRG) NCDST
Newell Rubbermaid Inc. (NWL) ISBI
O'Reilly Automotive, Inc. (ORLY) NCF
Owens-Illinois, Inc. (OI) ISBI
Patterson Companies, Inc. (PDCO) PRIM
Pioneer Natural Resources Company (PXD) LACERA
PPG Industries, Inc. (PPG) NCDST
Principal Financial Group, Inc. (PFG) ISBI
St. Jude Medical, Inc. (STJ) ISBI
TECO Energy, Inc. (TE) NCF
Teradata Corporation (TDC) NCDST
The Progressive Corporation (PGR) ISBI
The Western Union Company (WU) NCF
Roper Industries, Inc. (ROP) LACERA
Rowan Companies, Inc. (RDC) NCDST
Stanley Black & Decker, Inc. (SWK) NCDST
Unum Group (UNM) LACERA
Wyndham Worldwide Corporation (WYN) NCF
 
Panel B: Additional Management Proposals
Expected to go to a Vote
Allegheny Technologies Incorporated (ATI) OPERS
 
Panel C: Management Proposals Following
Successful 2012 Precatory Proposals
MEMC Electronic Materials, Inc. (WFR) NCDST
Quest Diagnostics Incorporated (DGX) ISBI


Table 2: Successful Engagements Following 2013 Proposals

Company Proponent
Panel A: Management Proposals to Declassify that
Have Gone or Will Go to a Vote (Partial)
Apache Corporation (APA) ISBI
Autoliv, Inc. (ALV) LACERA
Baxter International Inc. (BAX) NCF
Best Buy Co, Inc. (BBY) NCF
CareFusion Corporation (CFN) NCF
CarMax, Inc. (KMX) NCF
Centene Corporation (CNC) ISBI
Cerner Corporation (CERN) ISBI
CF Industries Holdings, Inc. (CF) LACERA
Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc. (CMG) ISBI
Cognizant Technology Solutions Corporation (CTSH) LACERA
Crown Castle International Corp. (CCI) SERS
DENTSPLY International Inc. (XRAY) LACERA
Edwards Lifesciences Corporation (EW) ISBI
EQT Corporation (EQT) OPERS
F5 Networks, Inc. (FFIV) ISBI
FLIR Systems, Inc. (FLIR) NCF
FMC Corporation (FMC) NCF
Hess Corporation (HES) NCDST
Johnson Controls, Inc. (JCI) PRIM
Lexmark International (LXK) NCDST
Limited Brands, Inc. (LTD) ISBI
Lorillard, Inc. (LO) ISBI
Manpower Inc. (MAN) SBA
Marathon Petroleum Corporation (MPC) NCF
Masco Corporation (MAS) ISBI
Monsanto Company (MON) PRIM
Moody's Corporation (MCO) NCF
NII Holdings, Inc. (NIHD) SBA
Owens Corning (OC) ISBI
People's United Financial, Inc. (PBCT) NCDST
PPG Industries, Inc. (PPG) NCDST
QEP Resources, Inc. (QEP) ISBI
Red Hat, Inc. (RHT) LACERA
Reinsurance Group of America, Inc. (RGA) SERS
Ryder System, Inc. (R) NCDST
salesforce.com, inc. (CRM) NCF
Snap-On Inc. (SNA) NCDST
SPX Corporation (SPW) SBA
St. Jude Medical Inc. (STJ) ISBI
The J. M. Smucker Company (SJM) LACERA
The Mosaic Company (MOS) OPERS
United Natural Foods, Inc. (UNFI) ISBI
Vulcan Materials Company (VMC) ISBI
Xylem Inc. (XYL) NCF
 
Panel B: Companies Declassified through Bylaw Amendments
Bemis Company (BMS) NCDST
CIGNA Corporation (CI) OPERS
Lincoln National Corporation (LNC) SERS
Urban Outfitters, Inc. (URBN) ISBI
V.F. Corporation (VFC) NCF


Table 3: Successful Engagements Following 2014 Proposals (Partial)

Company Proponent
Aecom Technology Corporation (ACM) ISBI
Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. (APD) NCF
Ashland Inc. (ASH) ISBI
BorgWarner Inc. (BWA) NCF
Costco Wholesale Corporation (COST) NCF
Foot Locker, Inc. (FL) NCDST
Hertz Global Holdings, Inc. (HTZ) ISBI
Huntington Ingalls Industries, Inc. (HII) ISBI
Huntsman Corporation (HUN) SBA
Jacobs Engineering Group Inc. (JEC) NCF
Jarden Corporation (JAH) NCDST
Kansas City Southern (KSU) ISBI
Kellogg Company (K) NCDST
NCR Corporation (NCR) SBA
Rockwell Collins, Inc. (COL) NCF
SCANA Corporation (SCG) NCF
SPX Corporation (SPW) SBA
St. Jude Medical, Inc. (STJ) ISBI
Teradata Corporation (TDC) NCDST
Varian Medical Systems, Inc. (VAR) NCF
United States Steel Corporation (X) NCDST
WESCO International, Inc. (WCC) SBA